Both pleasant and unpleasant
smells may help reduce the urge to smoke, according to a new study. In
a recent study published in the American Psychological Association?s journal
Experimental and Clinical Pharmacology (Vol. 7, No. 2), researchers
from the University of Pittsburgh analyzed smokers' responses to a variety
of aromas.
The researchers looked at 58 smokers between the ages of 18 and 35 who
sniffed extracts of coconut, banana, peppermint, and lemon as well as camphor-based
cough suppressant, vinegar, and floral-scented shampoo. Odorless distilled
water was sniffed by a control group. Participants triggered their smoking
urges by lighting and then putting out their cigarettes. They later reported
whether their urge to smoke was decreased by each of the odors.
The study's findings suggest pleasant and unpleasant smells reduced
the participants' urge to smoke. The researchers were also able to rule
out the act of sniffing as a factor in reduced smoking urge. Results showed
that those sniffing both pleasant and offensive smells reported reduced
urges to smoke compared to those sniffing odorless distilled water. However,
the researchers reported that participants' facial expressions indicated
that odors triggering expressions associated with positive emotion were
more effective than those producing expressions related to negative emotion.
Still, the practical applications of this study are unknown, said Michael
Sayette, PhD, associate professor of psychology at the University of Pittsburgh
and co-author of the study. "This is preliminary research," Dr. Sayette
noted. "It?s premature to say that going into your garden and smelling
flowers will help you quit smoking. My advice to those who are trying to
quit smoking is to contact an approved smoking cessation program."
However, Dr. Sayette believes his research opens an avenue ripe for
further investigation ? whether aromatherapy has any value in smoking cessation.
One of the questions the study did not address is how long the smoking
urge abated. Dr. Sayette said this information could prove valuable in
the future, even if the craving is staved off only momentarily. "If it
lasts only 40 seconds we might think, 'What good is that?'" Dr. Sayette
said. "It might be more valuable than one would think. Maybe in that minute
the smoker can buy some time to make a better decision and leave a high-risk
situation. Of course, this is all speculative."
Frank Baker, PhD, vice president of behavioral research for the American
Cancer Society (ACS) and director of the ACS's Behavioral Research Center,
agreed with Dr. Sayette?s assessment of the study?s findings. "It?s a well-designed
study that raises some provocative questions," Dr. Baker said. "Smelling
pleasant odors seems to be a good first step in distracting people from
smoking. But we have to be careful not to over-interpret the results."
Like Dr. Sayette, Dr. Baker cautions smokers not to consider smelling
certain odors as an alternative therapy to current smoking cessation programs,
such as nicotine replacement and counseling.
If future research reveals that use of odors to curb smoking is valuable,
Dr. Sayette said it's likely that it will be as an addition to an integrated
smoking cessation program that includes several smoking cessation techniques.
ACS News Center stories are provided as a source of cancer-related
news and are not intended to be used as
press releases.
|