|
Summary: Are
smokers and coffee drinkers at a greater risk for ovarian
cancer?
Harvard Medical School researchers analyzed data from the Brigham and
Women's Hospital-based Nurses'
Health Study to look for associations
between cigarette
smoking, alcohol use, and caffeine intake and the
likelihood a woman might develop ovarian cancer. The results were
published online this week in Cancer, the American
Cancer Society's
peer-reviewed journal.
They found that cigarette smoking had no effect on whether a
woman might develop ovarian cancer overall, although there did appear
to be a higher risk for mucinous
ovarian tumors, a rare form of the
disease. Researchers could not establish a link with alcohol use,
either. They did find that caffeine intake might decrease a woman's
risk, but not if a woman used oral contraceptives or postmenopausal
hormone therapy.
Why It's
Important: Researchers have identified several risk
factors for developing ovarian cancer, and many of them—age
and family
history, for example—are outside a woman's control. Studies like this one might help identify risk factors women can control, like their diet.
This study also aims to clarify conflicting results about the
role of diet and other lifestyle factors in predicting ovarian cancer.
Links between certain foods or nutrients and ovarian cancer--be it
dairy,
carrots,
or folic
acid--remain confusing at best. See our
document, Common
Questions about Diet and Cancer,
for more information on this topic.
What's Already
Known: There are several known risk factors for ovarian
cancer. Half of all ovarian cancers are found in women over 63. The
more weight you have to lose, the higher your risk. A family
history of
ovarian cancer increases your chance of developing ovarian cancer; certain fertility drugs may also raise the risk.
Taking birth control pills, especially over many years, has
been shown to cut ovarian cancer risk, but the role of combined hormone
replacement therapy is uncertain, and estrogen replacement therapy
could increase risk, especially if taken over a long period of time.
For more, see Menopausal
Hormone Therapy and Cancer Risk.
We know that alcohol use is linked with cancers of the mouth,
pharynx (throat), larynx (voice box), esophagus, liver, and breast, and
possibly of the colon and rectum, as well. Drinkers who smoke are at an
even greater risk than those who engage in either behavior alone.
Coffee, once thought to increase risk for cancer, especially of the
pancreas, stomach, and colon, has yet to be linked with any of these,
nor has the caffeine from other sources such as soda, chocolate, or
tea.
How This Study
Was Done: Researchers examined questionnaires addressing
smoking and dietary habits that were filed every 2 years by Nurses'
Health Study participants over a 28-year period (1976 – 2007). The
portion of the questionnaire asking about smoking status first appeared
in 1976, and the dietary portion was introduced a little later, in
1980.
On each questionnaire, the women were asked whether they were
current or past smokers, and if they had smoked, the age they started
and the number of packs smoked per day. Alcohol intake was measured by
the amount of beer, wine, or liquor consumed in a year's time.
Participants were asked about the amount and type of
caffeine-containing foods and beverages they consumed. The researchers
also collected data on body mass index, reproductive history, oral
contraceptive and postmenopausal hormone use, and family history.
The researchers analyzed data on smoking status, smoking
duration, and pack years (calculated by multiplying the number of packs
smoked per day by the number of years smoked), then looked to see if
those numbers had any bearing on ovarian cancer diagnosis. They did the
same for caffeine intake—measured by the cups of coffee, tea, or cola
consumed in a week. They assessed the relationship between smoking
status and ovarian cancer among 110,454 women, and examined the records
of 80,253 women for links between alcohol and caffeine use.
What Was Found:
Of the group, 737 reported an ovarian cancer diagnosis, 69 of which
were mucinous. The risk of having a mucinous tumor was tied to smoking
duration and pack years. Researchers found a link between caffeine
intake and lower ovarian cancer risk, but that relationship was only
seen among the women who never used oral contraceptives or took
hormones after menopause. There wasn't a clear connection between
alcohol use and ovarian cancer.
The Bottom Line:
While this data may be somewhat comforting to a woman with a family
history of ovarian cancer and a personal history of alcohol use and
cigarette use, it doesn't offer a clear-cut strategy for women hoping
to reduce their risk.
Although smoking isn't linked to a higher risk of developing
ovarian cancer according to this study, it is known to cause cancers of
the lung, larynx, mouth, pharynx (throat), esophagus, and bladder, and
has been conclusively linked to acute myeloid leukemia, and cancers of
the cervix, kidney, pancreas, and stomach. It's also a known risk factor for a host of other medical problems, including cardiovascular disease. Alcohol use has been
associated cancers of the mouth, pharynx (throat), larynx (voice box),
esophagus, liver, and breast, and is especially advised against for
women at a high risk for breast cancer.
But should women drink more caffeine? The researchers say
their finding of a lower risk should be viewed with caution. While it's
been suggested that drinking coffee might protect against everything
from type-2 diabetes to memory decline, this study does not provide
concrete answers about caffeine's effect on ovarian cancer.
"Researchers will need to study the mechanism of the observed
effect of caffeine to see if they can translate that into clinical
recommendations. In the meantime, it is not recommended that women
alter their caffeine consumption in an effort to lower risk," said
Debbie Saslow, PhD, American Cancer Society, Director of Breast and
Gynecologic Cancer, after the study was released.
For more information on the relationship between diet and
lifestyle factors and cancer, see our document, Common
Questions about Diet and Cancer.
Citation:
"Caffeine, Alcohol, Smoking, and the Risk of Incident Ovarian Cancer."
Published in the March, 1, 2008, Cancer (Vol. 112,
Issue 5:1-9). First
author: Shelly S. Tworoger, PhD, Channing Laboratory, Department of
Medicine, Brigham and Women's Hospital, Harvard Medical School, Boston,
Massachusetts.
ACS News Center stories are provided as a source of cancer-related
news and are not intended to be used as
press releases.
|