|
Introduction
Many terms are used to describe smokeless tobacco products,
such as oral, chewing, snuff, spit and spitless tobacco. All forms of
oral tobacco contain known carcinogens (cancer-causing agents). They
can cause cancer of the mouth and pancreas and many other health
problems, such as gum disease, destruction of the bone sockets around
the teeth, and tooth loss. They also cause bad breath and stained
teeth.
Smokeless tobacco is less lethal than cigarettes, but all
forms of tobacco pose significant health risks. This document is
intended to describe smokeless tobacco products, how they are used, and
outline some of the health consequences linked to smokeless tobacco use
and marketing of these products.
What is smokeless tobacco?
Smokeless tobacco commonly comes in 2 basic forms, snuff and
chewing tobacco. In addition to these, several other forms of smokeless
tobacco have also been introduced.
Snuff
is finely ground tobacco packaged in cans or pouches. It is sold in 2
forms: dry and moist. Moist snuff is used by placing a "pinch," "dip,"
"lipper," or "quid," between the lower lip or cheek and gum. Nicotine
is absorbed through the tissues of the mouth. Moist snuff is also
available in small, teabag-like pouches or sachets that can be placed
between the cheek and gum; these are designed to be both "smoke-free"
and "spit-free" and are marketed as a "discreet" way to use tobacco.
Dry snuff is sold in a powdered form and is used by sniffing or
inhaling the dry snuff powder up the nose.
Chewing tobacco
comes in the form of long strands of loose leaves, plugs, or twists of
tobacco. Portions of this, commonly called "plugs," "wads," or "chew,"
are chewed or placed between the cheek and gum or teeth. Nicotine is
absorbed through the mouth tissues. The user spits out the brown juice
-- saliva that soaked through the tobacco.
Alternative
smokeless tobacco products come in many forms. Snus
(sounds like "snoose") is a form of moist snuff commonly used in Sweden
and Norway. It is now being test-marketed in the United States. It is
made of air-cured tobacco, water, salt, and flavor additives. It has
less tobacco-specific nitrosamines than most smokeless products used in
the US, because the tobacco is not fermented. (Tobacco-specific
nitrosamines are chemicals that are known to cause cancer.) Snus is
most commonly packaged in small pouches, but can also be used like
loose moist snuff. A 2004 study showed that people who switch to
Swedish snus have smaller amounts of certain cancer-causing agents in
their bodies than those who use the more common smokeless products.
However, those who used snus still had notably higher levels of these
cancer-causing agents than people who used nicotine replacement
patches. A variety of other smokeless products are also available in
the United States. These include low-nitrosamine pouches of snuff, such
as Exalt® or Revel® and
tobacco lozenges such as Ariva® and Stonewall®.
Marketing of Smokeless Tobacco
Products
Tobacco companies have responded to the popular laws that ban
smoking in public places by making and selling smokeless products that
can be used in no-smoking settings. They use ad slogans such as
"Anytime. Anywhere" and "No Smoking, No Problem" to target smokers with
nicotine cravings in smoke-free settings. Free samples and coupons are
also offered to encourage people to try these new products as a less
dangerous alternative to smoking. Without smokeless products, these
smokers might be motivated to quit smoking completely.
The tobacco industry is also promoting the idea that switching
to smokeless products is an effective way to quit smoking. These claims
are implied rather than made outright, to avoid regulation of these
products as drugs. There is no sound evidence that smokeless tobacco
products can actually help smokers quit. Because these products contain
tobacco, they are not required to be tested to be sure they meet Food
and Drug Administration (FDA) standards. This is not the case with
proven treatments for tobacco addiction, such as nicotine replacement
products, antidepressants, nicotine receptor blockers, and behavioral
therapies. These standard treatments have been tested at length and
proven to be effective ways to help people quit smoking.
There are two serious problems with the current marketing of
smokeless tobacco. The first is that their ads encourage smokers to use
these products to meet their nicotine cravings in settings where they
cannot smoke. This wipes out one of the benefits of smoke-free laws.
Smokers who delay quitting by using smokeless products while continuing
to smoke increase their risk of lung cancer. How long a person smokes
is by far the most important factor in lung cancer risk.
The second problem from uncontrolled marketing of these
products is that it may worsen the problem of tobacco use among
teenagers. The last time that US tobacco companies aggressively
promoted smokeless products, they stimulated a large increase in the
use of moist snuff among teenagers, especially adolescent males. But
very few smokers switched.
What are the risks of using
smokeless tobacco?
Smokeless tobacco products are not a safe substitute for
tobacco smoking.
Harmful health effects include:
- oral (mouth) cancer
- pancreatic cancer
- addiction to nicotine
- leukoplakia (white sores in the mouth that can lead to
cancer)
- receding gums (gums slowly shrink away from around the
teeth)
- bone
loss around the roots of the teeth
- abrasion (scratching and wearing
down) of teeth
- staining of teeth
- bad breath
Leukoplakia is a white sore or patch in the mouth that can
become cancerous. Studies have consistently found high rates of
leukoplakia at the place in the mouth where users place the "chew." One
study found that almost 3 out of 4 of daily users of moist snuff and
chewing tobacco had non-cancerous or pre-cancerous lesions (sores) in
the mouth. The longer you use oral tobacco, the more likely you are to
have leukoplakia.
Many regular smokeless tobacco users have receding gums and
bone loss around the teeth. The surface of the tooth root may be
exposed where gums have shrunk back. Tobacco can irritate or destroy
the gum tissue.
Smokeless tobacco may also play a role in heart disease and
high blood pressure. Men who switched from cigarettes to snuff or
chewing tobacco in a large American Cancer Society study had higher
death rates from heart disease, stroke, cancer of the mouth and lung,
and all causes of death combined than former smokers who stopped using
all tobacco products. It is unclear whether the heart disease was
caused by the smokeless products in this study, because there have been
few large, long-term studies to identify health problems caused by
these products.
The snuff and chewing tobacco products most widely used in the
United States contain very high levels of tobacco-specific causing
nitrosamines. These carcinogens (cancer-causing agents) cause lung
cancer in animals, even when injected.
How do the risks of using
smokeless tobacco compare to cigarette smoking?
Smokeless tobacco products are less lethal than cigarettes.
However, these products have not been proven to be effective in helping
smokers quit. Smokers who delay quitting by using smokeless products
between cigarettes greatly increase their risk of lung cancer. They
also set themselves up for new health problems caused by smokeless
tobacco.
Who uses smokeless tobacco?
Data from the US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention
(CDC) showed that among adults aged 18 and older in 2004, about 3% of
people (6% of men and less than 1% of women) were current users of
smokeless tobacco.
Rates among young people, however, are higher. According to
the CDC's 2005 survey, about 14% of male high school students and 2% of
female high school students were using smokeless tobacco. The CDC 2004
Tobacco Survey reported that, of middle school students, 4% of the boys
and 2% of the girls reported using smokeless tobacco at least once in
the 30 days before the survey. Teens who use smokeless tobacco are more
likely to smoke later.
Certain factors seem to be linked to whether or not young
people will use tobacco. They include:
- peer pressure
- local lifestyles and fashions
- general
attitudes toward authority
- economic conditions
- examples set by
teachers and school staff
- presence of gangs
- use of illegal drugs
and alcohol
In 2003, more than 1 in 3 major league baseball players used
smokeless tobacco, mainly moist snuff. Athletes are the largest
marketing source for smokeless tobacco, and are often seen on TV using
it during a game. They have a lot influence as negative role models for
youth.
A more recent influence on the use of smokeless tobacco is the
newly enacted smoking bans many states are enforcing. In light of these
bans, tobacco companies are putting new marketing emphasis on their
smokeless tobacco products. New smokeless tobacco products are being
advertised as alternatives to cigarettes in places where smoking is not
allowed. It supports the tobacco industry when smokers try substituting
these products instead of trying to quit.
Smokers who postpone quitting by using smokeless tobacco or
oral tobacco products as a nicotine fix while in smoke-free settings do
not decrease their lung cancer risk because they are still smoking
cigarettes. Lung cancer risk is affected most by how long a person
smokes.
Quitting Smokeless Tobacco
Quitting smokeless tobacco is not easy, but you can do it. To
have the best chance of quitting successfully, you need to know what
you're up against, what your options are, and where to go for help.
You'll find this information here.
Why is it so hard to quit?
Nicotine
It is hard because nicotine, a drug found naturally in
tobacco, is highly addictive. In fact, it is as addictive as heroin or
cocaine. Over time, users become physically and psychologically
dependent on nicotine. Studies have shown that they must deal with both
of these dependencies to be successful at quitting and staying quit.
Where nicotine
goes and how long it stays: Nicotine enters the
bloodstream from the mouth and is carried throughout the body. It
affects many parts of the body, including your heart and blood vessels,
your hormones, your metabolism, and your brain. During pregnancy,
nicotine freely crosses the placenta. Nicotine has been found in
amniotic fluid and the umbilical cord blood of newborn infants.
Many different factors can affect how quickly the body gets
rid of nicotine. In general, a regular oral tobacco user will probably
have nicotine or its by-products, such as cotinine, in the body for
about 3 or 4 days after stopping.
How nicotine
hooks smokers: Nicotine causes pleasurable
feelings that make the tobacco user want to use more. It also acts as a
kind of depressant by interfering with the flow of information between
nerve cells. As the nervous system adapts to nicotine, tobacco users
tend to increase the amount of tobacco they use, and hence the amount
of nicotine in their blood. This is called tolerance. More tobacco must
be used to get the same effect. Eventually, the tobacco user reaches a
certain nicotine level and then keeps up the usage to maintain this
level of nicotine.
Smokeless tobacco delivers a high dose of nicotine. An average
dose from snuff is 3.6 milligrams (mg) and from chewing tobacco is 4.5
mg -- compared to 1 to 2 mg from a cigarette. Despite this difference,
blood levels of nicotine throughout the day are similar among smokers
and those who use smokeless tobacco.
Nicotine
withdrawal: Stopping smokeless tobacco use causes
symptoms of nicotine withdrawal that are much like those smokers get
when they quit. In a Swedish study, oral snuff users reported having as
much trouble giving up tobacco as did cigarette smokers trying to quit
smoking. Evidence also suggests that when regular snuff users can't use
snuff, they will smoke cigarettes to satisfy their need for nicotine.
When smokeless tobacco users try to cut back or quit, the lack
of nicotine leads to withdrawal symptoms. Withdrawal is both physical
and mental. Physically, the body is reacting to the absence of
nicotine. Mentally, the user is faced with giving up a habit, which
calls for a major change in behavior. Both must be dealt with if
quitting is to be successful.
If a person has used tobacco regularly for a few weeks or
longer and suddenly stops or greatly reduces the amount, he or she will
have withdrawal symptoms. Symptoms usually start within a few hours of
the last dip or chew and peak about 2 to 3 days later. Withdrawal
symptoms can last for a few days to up to several weeks.
Withdrawal symptoms can include any of the following:
- dizziness (which may last only 1-2 days after
quitting)
- depression
- feelings of frustration, impatience, and anger
- anxiety
- irritability
- trouble sleeping (including trouble falling asleep and
staying asleep, and having bad dreams or even nightmares)
- trouble concentrating
- restlessness
- headaches
- tiredness
- increased appetite
These uncomfortable feelings can lead you to start using
tobacco again to boost blood levels of nicotine to stop symptoms. For
information on coping with withdrawal, please see the section "How to
Quit."
Why Quit?
There are many reasons to stick it out through withdrawal and
quit using smokeless tobacco for good. Health reasons, as mentioned
earlier, are the obvious ones. But consider the following as well.
Social Acceptance
Chewing and dipping carry a heavy social stigma, especially
with dating partners. Bad breath, gum disease, and discolored teeth are
very unappealing. The spitting required by most smokeless tobacco can
be offensive and has a potential health risk as well.
Cost
A tobacco habit can be expensive. It isn't hard to figure out
how much you spend on tobacco: multiply how much money you spend on
tobacco every day by 365 (days per year). The amount may surprise you.
Now multiply that by the number of years you have been using tobacco
and that amount will probably astound you.
Multiply the cost per year by 10 (for the upcoming 10 years)
and ask yourself what you would rather do with that much money. Do you
really want to continue wasting your money with nothing to show for it
except possible health problems?
Setting an Example
If you have children in your life, you want to set a good
example for them. When asked, nearly all smokeless tobacco users say
they don't want their children to chew or dip. You can become a good
role model for them if you quit now.
Quitting Smokeless Tobacco
Surveys show that most people who use snuff or chew would like
to quit. In 1 survey, more than half of the respondents said they would
try to quit in the next year.
In many ways, quitting smokeless tobacco is a lot like
quitting smoking. Both involve tobacco products that contain nicotine,
and both involve the physical and psychological parts of addiction.
Many of the ways to handle the psychological hurdles of quitting are
the same. But there are 2 parts of quitting that are unique for oral
tobacco users:
- There is often a stronger need for oral substitutes (having
something in the mouth) to take the place of the chew, snuff, or
pouch.
- The disappearance of mouth sores and gum problems caused by
the
smokeless tobacco provides a readily visible benefit of quitting.
Help With Psychological
Addiction
Some people are able to quit on their own, without the help of
others or the use of medicines. But for many tobacco users, it can be
hard to break the social and emotional ties to chewing or dipping while
getting over nicotine withdrawal symptoms at the same time.
Fortunately, there are many sources of support out there -- both formal
and informal.
Telephone-based Help Programs
Most states run some type of free telephone-based quitting
program, which links callers with trained counselors. These specialists
help plan a quit method that fits each person's own pattern of tobacco
use. With guidance from a counselor, quitters can avoid common mistakes
that may hurt a quit attempt.
Telephone counseling is also more convenient for many people
than some other support programs. It doesn't require transportation or
childcare, and it's available nights and weekends. Counselors may
suggest a combination of methods including local classes, self-help
brochures, medicines, and/or a network of family and friends. One
review of studies about smokeless tobacco use found that telephone
counseling had a helpful effect on people trying to quit.
Tobacco users can get help finding a program to help them quit
tobacco. These are sometimes called tobacco cessation (sess-a-shun)
programs. One such telephone service is the American Cancer Society’s
Quitline® tobacco cessation program. You can
find out more about this
and other programs in your area by calling ACS at 1-800-ACS-2345.
Support of Family, Friends, and
Quit Programs
Many former tobacco users say a support network of family and
friends was very important during their quit attempt. Other people who
may offer support and encouragement are co-workers, your family doctor
or dentist, and members of support groups for quitters. You can check
with your employer, health insurance company, or local hospital to find
support groups; or call the ACS at 1-800-ACS-2345. You can also check
the "Additional Resources" section for information on Nicotine
Anonymous.
What to Look for in a Tobacco
Cessation Group or Class
Tobacco cessation programs are designed to help users
recognize and cope with problems that come up during quitting and to
provide support and encouragement in staying quit. While many programs
focus mainly on smokers, most are open to smokeless tobacco users as
well.
Studies have shown that the best programs will include either
one-on-one or group counseling. There is a strong link between the
intensity of counseling and the success rate. In general, the more
intense the program, the greater the chance of success.
Intensity may be increased by having more or longer sessions
or by increasing the number of weeks over which the sessions are given.
So when considering a program, look for one that has the following:
- session length -- at least 20 to 30 minutes per
session
- number of sessions -- at least 4 to 7 sessions
- number of weeks -- at
least 2 weeks
Be sure the leader of the group has training in tobacco
cessation. Some communities have a Nicotine Anonymous group that holds
regular meetings. This group applies the principles of Alcoholics
Anonymous to tobacco addiction. There is no fee to attend.
Often your local American Cancer Society or local health
department will sponsor quitting classes. Call 1-800-ACS-2345 for more
information.
There are some programs to be cautious about as well. Not all
programs are ethical. Be wary of programs that:
- promise instant, easy success with no effort on your
part;
- use injections or pills with "secret" ingredients;
- charge a very high
fee – check with the Better Business Bureau if you have
doubts;
- are
not willing to give you references from people who have used the
program.
A Word About Success Rates
Before you sign up for a tobacco cessation class or program,
you may wonder what its success rate is. That's a hard question to
answer for many reasons. First, not all programs define “success” in
the same way. Does success mean that a person is not using tobacco at
the end of the program? after 3 months? 6 months? or a year? If a
program you're considering claims a certain success rate, ask for more
details on how success is defined and what kind of follow-up is done to
confirm the rate.
The truth is that programs to help you quit tobacco may give
you more of an edge than trying to quit on your own, but they (like
other programs that treat addictions) often have a fairly low overall
success rate. This does not mean they are not worthwhile, or that you
should be discouraged. Your own success in quitting is what really
counts, and that is under your control.
What About Medicines?
Tobacco addiction has both an emotional and a physical
component. Physical addiction can cause you to go through withdrawal
symptoms if you try to quit, and for many people this is a difficult
part of addiction to overcome.
Nicotine Replacement Therapy
Nicotine replacements (nicotine substitutes) provide nicotine
without the other harmful ingredients in tobacco. For cigarette
smokers, nicotine replacement therapy (NRT) has been proven to help
reduce withdrawal symptoms. Together with counseling or other support,
it doubles the chances that a smoker will quit. Less information is
available on how much NRT helps smokeless tobacco users quit. Since
both smokers and smokeless users are addicted to nicotine, it makes
sense to some smokeless tobacco users to try it.
The US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has approved several
NRT products as effective aids for helping people to quit smoking.
These include:
- nicotine gum
- nicotine patch
- nicotine lozenges
- nicotine
inhaler
- nicotine nasal spray
(For more information on these products, see the American
Cancer Society document, Guide
to Quitting Smoking.)
However, none of these products has been FDA approved
specifically to help people quit smokeless tobacco, as their
effectiveness in this situation has not been proven. The results of
several small studies have been mixed, and larger studies are needed.
Still, NRT may be useful in helping you quit, or at least in helping to
reduce your cravings.
Nicotine gum, patches, and lozenges can be bought "over the
counter" (without a prescription). Nicotine nasal spray and nasal
inhalers are available only with a doctor's prescription.
For smokeless tobacco users, some types of NRT may be more
helpful than others. From a behavioral standpoint, nicotine gum and
lozenges are oral substitutes that are the most like using smokeless
tobacco. They also allow you to control your dosage to help keep
cravings at bay. The nicotine inhaler may not be as useful for
smokeless tobacco users, as it is designed to look and feel like a
cigarette filter tip. The nicotine patch gives a steady dose of
nicotine but may not help with strong cravings. It may be more useful
for people who prefer once-a-day convenience. A 2007 study compared
higher-dose nicotine patches with the usual NRT doses in heavy users of
smokeless tobacco. The researchers found that higher doses were more
helpful in reducing withdrawal symptoms.
No matter which type of NRT you choose, make sure to follow
the package instructions and don't use any tobacco, including smokeless
tobacco, when using nicotine replacement. You may want to talk with
your doctor, dentist, or pharmacist before using any of these products.
Getting the Most From Nicotine
Replacement
Nicotine replacement therapy only deals with the physical part
of withdrawal. These products are best used in combination with other
quitting aids such as group sessions or counseling. They may reduce
withdrawal symptoms, allowing you to concentrate on dealing with the
mental and emotional aspects of addiction.
If you choose to use it, the most effective time to start NRT
is at the beginning of an attempt to quit. Often tobacco users attempt
to quit first on their own, then decide to try NRT. You should not use
nicotine replacement if you plan to continue to use any tobacco
product. The combined dose of nicotine can be dangerous to your health.
Tobacco users who are pregnant or have heart disease should
talk to a doctor before using over-the-counter nicotine replacement.
Prescription Medicines
Bupropion
Bupropion (Zyban®) is a prescription
antidepressant in an
extended-release form that reduces symptoms of nicotine withdrawal. It
is not a form of nicotine replacement. This drug acts on chemicals in
the brain that are related to nicotine craving. Bupropion is FDA
approved as an aid in quitting smoking, but it is not clear if it is
useful for smokeless tobacco users as well. A 2007 study found that it
helped reduce cravings and weight gain in people who were trying to
quit smokeless tobacco. In that clinical trial, the group taking
bupropion was no more successful at quitting than the group taking
placebo (sugar pills). Bupropion works best in smokers if it is started
1 or 2 weeks before the quit date. The usual dosage is one or two 150
mg tablets per day. Talk to a doctor to find out if it might be an
option for you.
Bupropion can be used alone or together with NRT. It should
not be taken if you have ever had seizures, serious head injury,
bipolar (manic-depressive) illness, anorexia or bulimia (eating
disorders), or problems with heavy alcohol use.
Varenicline
Varenicline (Chantix™) is a newer
prescription medicine taken
as a pill twice a day. It works by interfering with nicotine receptors
in the brain, which has 2 effects. It lessens the physical pleasure
from taking in nicotine and helps lessen the symptoms of nicotine
withdrawal. Studies have shown it to be at least as effective as
bupropion (if not more so) in helping people quit smoking, at least in
the short term. Its effects against smokeless tobacco have not been
studied.
Substances Not Considered to Be
Drugs
Some newer tobacco-related and nicotine-containing products
have appeared in the past few years. Because they are not marketed to
treat nicotine addiction, the FDA doesn’t consider them drugs and
doesn’t regulate them. While some may be helpful, none of these
products has been proven effective.
Non-tobacco Snuff Products
These are sold in grocery and convenience stores or by mail
order. They are packaged like moist snuff in a tin and come in
different flavors. They are made from plant or herbs such as tea,
clover, mint leaves, or alfalfa, sometimes with added flavoring. They
can be used alone or mixed with regular snuff in an attempt to wean off
tobacco. They are generally considered safe, but are not reviewed by
the FDA. No studies have been done to find out how effective they are
in helping people quit tobacco.
Tobacco Lozenges and Pouches
Lozenges containing tobacco (Ariva®,
Stonewall®) and small,
tobacco-containing pouches (Revel®, Exalt®)
are now being marketed as
other ways for smokers to get nicotine in places where smoking is not
permitted, rather than as tobacco cessation aids. The FDA has ruled
that these are types of smokeless tobacco, not aids to quit smoking or
wean off tobacco; therefore, the FDA does not have authority over them.
There is no reason to think these products would have fewer health
risks than more common forms of smokeless tobacco.
Nicotine Lollipops and Lip Balms
In the past, some pharmacies made a product called a nicotine
lollipop. These lollipops often contained a product called nicotine
salicylate with a sugar sweetener. Nicotine salicylate is not approved
for pharmacy use by the FDA. The FDA has warned several pharmacies to
stop selling nicotine lollipops and lip balm, calling the products
"illegal." The FDA also said "the candy-like products present a risk of
accidental use by children."
Other similar smoking cessation products may not use nicotine
salicylate, and may be legal. But they still pose a risk for children
if they are not well-labeled and stored safely.
Nicotine Water and Nicotine
Wafers
These products have been sold in recent years as ways to get
nicotine in places where smoking is not allowed. They are not marketed
as aids to quitting smoking, but questions about their safety and
legality have been raised.
Other Unconventional Quitting
Aids
Hypnosis
Hypnosis methods vary a great deal, which makes it hard to
study as a way to quit tobacco. In general, reviews that looked at
studies of hypnosis to help people quit smoking have not supported it
as a quitting method that works. Even less study has been done on
hypnosis as a way to quit smokeless tobacco. Still, it might be useful
for some people. If you are interested in trying it, ask your doctor if
he or she can recommend a good hypnotherapist.
Acupuncture
This has also been used for quitting tobacco, but there little
evidence to show that it works. It involves inserting small needles
into the skin, usually around the ears. (For more information on
acupuncture, see the American Cancer Society document, Acupuncture.)
For a list of local physician acupuncturists, contact the American
Academy of Medical Acupuncture at 1-800-521-2262. Low-level laser
therapy is a related technique, which also has very little evidence to
support its effectiveness (see the American Cancer Society document,
Cold
Laser Therapy).
Tobacco Deterrents
These include over-the-counter products that change the taste
of tobacco, "quitting diets" that are supposed to curb nicotine
cravings, and combinations of vitamins. There is little scientific
evidence to support claims that these methods work.
"Homeopathic" Aids and Herbal
Supplements
Because they are marketed as dietary supplements (as opposed
to drugs), these products don't need FDA approval to be sold. The
manufacturers don't have to prove they're effective, or even safe. Be
sure to look closely at the label of any product claiming it can help
you quit tobacco. Dietary supplements and homeopathic remedies have no
proven track record of helping people quit tobacco (see the American
Cancer Society document, Homeopathy.)
How to Quit
Tobacco users often say, "Don't tell me why to quit, tell me
how." There is no one right way to quit, but there are some key
elements in quitting for good. These 4 factors are crucial:
- making the decision to quit
- setting a quit date and
choosing a quit plan
- dealing with withdrawal
- staying quit
(maintenance)
Making the Decision to Quit
The decision to quit tobacco use is one that only you can
make. Others may want you to quit, but in order for you to get through
the first few weeks without tobacco, the real commitment must come from
you.
Researchers have looked into how and why people stop tobacco
use. They have some ideas, or models, of how this happens.
The Health Belief Model says that you will be more likely to
stop using tobacco if you:
- believe that you could get a tobacco-related disease and
this worries you
- believe that you can make an honest attempt at
quitting
- believe that the benefits of quitting outweigh the benefits
of continuing tobacco use
- know of someone who has had health problems
as a result of their tobacco use
How Can I Know If I'm Ready to
Quit?
The Stages of Change Model identifies the stages that you go
through when you make a change in behavior. Here are the stages as they
apply to quitting tobacco use:
- Pre-contemplation:
At this stage, the tobacco user is not
seriously thinking about quitting right now.
- Contemplation:
The
tobacco user is actively thinking about quitting but is not quite ready
to make a serious attempt yet. This person may say, "Yes, I'm ready to
quit, but the stress at work is too much," or "I don't want to gain
weight," or "I'm not sure if I can do it."
- Preparation:
Tobacco users
in the preparation stage seriously intend to quit in the next month and
often have tried to quit in the past 12 months. They usually have a
plan.
- Action:
This is the first 6 months when the user is actively
quitting.
- Maintenance: This
is the period of 6 months to 5 years
after quitting when the ex-user is aware of the danger of relapse and
take steps to avoid it.
Where do you fit in this model? If you are thinking about
quitting, setting a date and deciding on a plan will move you into the
preparation stage, the best place to start.
Make a List of Your Reasons for
Quitting
Tobacco users have many reasons for wanting to quit. We listed
some of them above. But what motivates you to quit may not be the same
as what motivates others. Think about making a list of the reasons you
want to quit -- one you can refer back to later if you’re feeling
tempted. The list might include some or all of the following, but be
sure to add your own reasons:
- I want to be healthier.
- I already have problems with my
gums/teeth, and I don’t want them to get worse.
- I don’t want to spend
money on this.
- I can’t chew/dip at work/school.
- I want to be able
to go to a movie/mall/ballgame without worrying about it.
- I want to
prove I can do it.
- I don’t want it to control me.
- The people I care
about don’t like it, and want me to quit.
- I want to set a good
example for my kids.
Setting a Quit Date and Deciding
on a Plan
Once you've made a decision to quit, you're ready to pick a
quit date. This is a very important step. Pick a specific day within
the next month as your "Quit Day." Picking a date too far in the future
allows you time to rationalize and change your mind. But do give
yourself enough time to prepare and come up with a plan.
You might choose a date that has a special meaning like a
birthday or anniversary, or the date of the Great American Smokeout
(the third Thursday in November each year). Or you may want to simply
pick a random date. Circle the date on your calendar. Make a strong,
personal commitment to quit on that day. There is no one right way to
quit. Some tobacco users prefer to quit "cold turkey" -- that is, they
stop completely all at once. They use tobacco until their Quit Day and
then stop. Others may cut down on tobacco for 1 or 2 weeks before their
Quit Day.
Another way involves cutting down on the number of times or
the amount you dip or chew each day. With this method, you gradually
reduce the amount of nicotine in your body.
Quitting tobacco is a lot like losing weight; it takes a
strong commitment over a long period of time. Users may wish there were
a magic bullet -- a pill or method that would make quitting painless
and easy. But there is nothing like that. Nicotine substitutes can help
reduce withdrawal symptoms, but they work best when used as part of a
quitting plan that addresses both the physical and psychological
components of quitting.
Some Steps to Help You Prepare
For Your Quit Day
- Pick the date and mark it on your calendar.
- Tell friends,
family, and co-workers about your Quit Day, and let them know how they
can help.
- Stock up on oral substitutes -- sunflower seeds, sugarless
gum, carrot sticks, beef jerky, cinnamon sticks, and/or sugarless hard
candy.
- Decide on a plan. Will you use nicotine replacement
therapy?
Will you attend a class or program? If so, sign up now. Find out where
and when they meet, so that you are ready.
- Consider seeing your doctor or dentist. Have them check
your mouth,
and discuss your plan for quitting with them.
- Set up a support
system. This could be a group class, Nicotine Anonymous, or a friend or
family member who has quit and is willing to help you.
- Make a list of
your "triggers" -- situations, places, or emotions that make you more
likely to chew or dip. Being aware of these can help you avoid them or
at least be ready for them.
- Think back to your past attempts to quit.
Try to figure out what worked and what did not work for you.
Successful quitting is a matter of planning and commitment,
not luck. Decide now on your own plan. Some options include joining a
tobacco cessation class, calling a cessation support line, going to
Nicotine Anonymous meetings, using nicotine replacement, or using
self-help materials such as books and pamphlets. For the best chance of
success, your plan should include 1 or more of these options.
On your Quit Day, follow these suggestions:
- Don't use tobacco. This means none, not even a
pinch!
- Get rid of all snuff or chew and related products.
- Keep active –
try walking, exercising, or doing other activities or hobbies.
- Keep
oral substitutes handy.
- Drink lots of water and juices.
- Begin using
nicotine replacement if that is your choice.
- Call a cessation support
line, attend a tobacco cessation class, or start following a self-help
plan.
- Avoid situations where the urge to dip or chew is
strong.
- Reduce or avoid alcohol.
- Think about changing your routine. Sit in a different chair
at home,
drive a new way to work, or choose foods and drinks that make tobacco
taste bad.
Dealing With Withdrawal
Withdrawal from nicotine has 2 parts:
- physical withdrawal
- psychological withdrawal
The physical withdrawal symptoms, while annoying, are not life
threatening. If you choose to use nicotine replacement, it can help
reduce many of these physical symptoms. But most users find that the
bigger challenge is the mental and emotional part of quitting.
If you have been using tobacco for any length of time, it has
likely become linked with many of your activities -- watching TV;
attending sporting events; fishing, camping, or hunting; or driving
your car. It will take time to "un-link" tobacco use from these
activities. That's why, even if you are using the patch or gum, you may
still have strong urges to use tobacco.
One way to overcome these urges or cravings is to recognize
rationalizations as they come up. A rationalization is a mistaken
belief that seems to make sense at the time but is not based on facts.
If you have tried to quit before, you’ll probably recognize some of
these common rationalizations:
- I’ll just use it to get through this rough spot.
- Today is
not a good day; I’ll quit tomorrow.
- It's my only vice.
- How bad is
tobacco, really? Uncle Harry chewed all his life and he lived to be
over 90.
- You've got to die of something.
- Life is no fun without
chewing (or dipping).
You probably can add more to the list. As you go through the
first few days without tobacco, write down any rationalizations as they
come up and recognize them for what they are: messages that can trap
you into going back to using tobacco. Use the ideas below to help you
keep your commitment to quitting.
Avoid
temptation. Stay away from people and places where you
are tempted to use tobacco. Later on you will be able to handle these
with more confidence.
Change your
habits. For example, switch to juices or water
instead of alcohol or coffee. Take a different route to work; take a
brisk walk instead of a chew.
Alternatives. Use
oral substitutes such as sunflower seeds,
sugarless gum or hard candy, or raw vegetables such as carrot sticks.
Activities. Exercise
or do hobbies that keep your hands busy
(such as woodworking, puzzles, gardening) and can help distract you
from the urge to use.
Deep breathing. When
the urge to use strikes, breathe deeply
and picture your lungs filling with fresh, clean air. Remind yourself
of why you are quitting and the benefits you'll gain.
Delay. If you feel
that you are on the verge of giving in,
delay. Tell yourself you must wait at least 10 minutes. Often this
simple trick will allow you to move beyond the immediate urge to use
tobacco.
Reward Yourself.
What you're doing is not easy, so you deserve
a reward. Put the money you would have spent on tobacco in a jar every
day and then buy yourself a weekly treat. Buy a magazine, go out to
eat, call a friend long-distance. Or save the money for a major
purchase. You can also reward yourself in ways that don't cost money:
take time out to read, work on a hobby, or take a relaxing bath.
Staying Quit (Maintenance)
Staying quit is the final, and most important, stage of the
process. You can use the same methods to stay quit as you did to help
you through withdrawal. Plan ahead for those times when you may be
tempted to use tobacco and think about alternatives and activities you
can use to cope with these situations.
More dangerous, perhaps, are the unexpected strong desires to
use tobacco that occur sometimes months (or even years) after you've
quit. To get through these without relapse, try the following:
- Review your reasons for quitting -- look at your list and
think of all the benefits to your health, your finances, and your
family.
- Remind yourself that there is no such thing as just one
chew
or dip.
- Ride out the desire. It will go away, but do not fool
yourself into
thinking you can have just one.
What If You Do Use Tobacco?
The difference between a slip and a relapse is within your
control. A slip is a one-time mistake that is quickly corrected. A
relapse is going back to your former habit. You can use the slip as an
excuse to go back to using tobacco, or you can look at what went wrong
and renew your commitment to staying off tobacco for good.
Even if you do relapse, try not to get too discouraged. Many
people are not able to quit for good on the first attempt. In fact, it
takes most people many attempts before quitting for good. What’s
important is figuring out what helped you in your attempt to quit and
what worked against you. You can then use this information to make a
stronger attempt at quitting the next time.
Weight Gain
Although it is well known that smokers often gain weight when
they quit, fewer studies have been done about quitting smokeless
tobacco. Researchers in a small 2007 study looked at people who were
trying to quit smokeless tobacco. They gave bupropion to one group, and
sugar pills (placebo) to the other. Even though there was no
significant difference in quit rates between the groups in the study,
there was a difference in weight gain among the people who quit
successfully. The researchers found that quitters who took the drug
gained an average of about 4 pounds, while those in the control group
gained about 7 pounds. These findings suggest that people who quit
smokeless tobacco have some risk of weight gain.
You are more likely to quit successfully if you deal with
quitting tobacco first, and then later take steps to reduce your
weight. While you are quitting, try to focus on ways to help you stay
healthy, rather than on your weight. Stressing about your weight may
make it harder to quit. Eat plenty of fruits and vegetables and limit
the fat. Be sure to drink plenty of water, and get enough sleep and
regular physical activity.
Walking is a great way to be physically active and increase
your chances of staying quit. Walking can help you by:
- reducing stress
- burning calories and toning muscles
- giving you something to do instead of thinking about
tobacco
No special equipment or clothing is needed for walking, other
than a pair of comfortable shoes. And you can do it pretty much anytime
or anywhere. Try the following:
- Walk around a shopping mall.
- Get off the bus one stop
before you usually do.
- Find a buddy to walk with during lunch time at
work.
- Take the stairs instead of the elevator.
- Walk with a friend, family member, or neighbor after
dinner.
- Push your baby in a stroller, walk your dog, or offer to
walk someone
else's dog.
Set a goal of 30 minutes of physical activity 5 or more times
a week. If you don't already exercise regularly, please check with your
doctor before starting an exercise program.
Dealing With Stress
Tobacco users often mention stress as one of the reasons for
going back to using tobacco. Stress is a part of all of our lives. The
difference is that tobacco users have come to use nicotine to help cope
with stress and unpleasant emotions. When quitting, you have to learn
new ways to handle them. This can be tough, especially during the first
few days. It’s important to let those around you know what you’re going
through and to ask them for their understanding. Nicotine replacement
can help to some extent, but for long-term success other strategies are
needed.
As mentioned before, physical activity is a good stress
reducer. It can also help with the short-term sense of depression that
some tobacco users have when they quit.
Stress-management classes and self-help books may also be
helpful. Check your community newspaper, library, or bookstore.
Spiritual practices such as prayer and meditation have been
used successfully with other addictions and are an integral part of
12-step recovery programs. These same principles can be applied to
tobacco cessation and may help with stress reduction.
Where Can I Go for Help?
It’s hard to give up tobacco. But if you are a tobacco user
you can quit! Many organizations offer information, counseling, and
other services focusing on how to quit and where to go for help. Other
good resources include your doctor, dentist, local hospital, or
employer. If you want to quit and need help, contact one of the
following organizations.
Centers for
Disease Control and Prevention
Office on Smoking
and Health
Telephone: 1-800-CDC-4636 (1-800-232-4636)
Internet Address: http://www.cdc.gov/tobacco/how2quit.htm
National Cancer
Institute
Cancer Information Service
Telephone: 1-877-448-7848
Internet Address: http://www.cancer.gov
Nicotine
Anonymous
Telephone: 1-877-TRY-NICA (1-877-879-6422)
Internet Address: http://www.nicotine-anonymous.org
Smokefree.gov
(Info
on state telephone-based counseling
programs)
Telephone: 1-800-QUITNOW (1-800-784-8669)
Internet Address: http://www.smokefree.gov
References
Agency for Health Care Policy and Research, Clinical Practice
Guideline on Smoking Cessation, No. 18, AHCPR, Rockville,
MD, April
1997.
American Cancer Society. Cancer
Facts & Figures 2008.
Atlanta, GA. 2008.
Benowitz NL. Drug therapy-pharmacology of smokeless tobacco
use: nicotine addiction and nicotine-related health consequences. In:
Smokeless Tobacco or Health: An International Perspective. Smoking and
Tobacco Control Monograph No.2. Bethesda (MD): US Department of Health
and Human Services, Public Health Service, National Institutes of
Health. NIH Publication No. 93-3461, 1992b:219-228. Available at:
http://cancercontrol.cancer.gov/tcrb/monographs/2/m2_4.pdf. Accessed
October 23, 2007.
Benowitz NL. Pharmacologic aspects of cigarette smoking and
nicotine addiction. N
Engl J Med. 1988;319:1318-1330.
Benowitz NL, Jacob P III, Yu L. Daily use of smokeless
tobacco: Systemic effects. Ann
Intern Med. 1989;111:112-116.
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC). Use of
smokeless tobacco among adults, 1991. MMWR. 1993. 42;263-266. Available
at: http://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/preview/mmwrhtml/00020232.htm. Accessed October
23, 2007.
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC). Tobacco use,
access, and exposure to tobacco in media among middle and high school
students – United States, 2004. MMWR. 2005;54;297-301. Available at:
http://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/preview/mmwrhtml/mm5412a1.htm. Accessed October 8,
2007.
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC). Youth Risk
Behavior Surveillance -- United States, 2005. Morbidity and Mortality
Weekly Report. 2006; 55(SS-5). Available at:
http://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/PDF/SS/SS5505.pdf. Accessed September 28, 2007.
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC). Smokeless
Tobacco Fact Sheet 2007. Available at:
http://www.cdc.gov/tobacco/data_statistics/Factsheets/smokeless_tobacco.htm.
Accessed 10/22/07.
Cogliano V, Straif K, Baan R, Grosse Y, Secretan B, El
Ghissass F. Smokeless tobacco and tobacco-related nitrosamines. Lancet
Oncol 2004: 5: 708.
Critchley JA, Unal B. Is smokeless tobacco a risk factor for
coronary heart disease? A systematic review of epidemiological studies.
Eur J Cardiovasc Prev
Rehabil 2004;11:101-12.
Dale LC, Ebbert JO, Glover ED, et al. Bupropion SR for the
treatment of smokeless tobacco use. Drug Alcohol Depend.
2007 Sep
6;90:56-63.
Ebbert JO, Dale LC, Patten CA, et al. Effect of high-dose
nicotine patch therapy on tobacco withdrawal symptoms among smokeless
tobacco users. Nicotine
Tob Res. 2007; 9:43-52.
Ebbert J, Montori V, Vickers K, et al. Interventions for
smokeless tobacco use cessation.
Cochrane Database Syst
Rev. 2007 Oct 17;(4):CD004306.
Elder JP, Wildey M, de Moor C, et al. The long-term prevention
of tobacco use among junior high school students: Classroom and
telephone interventions. Am
J Pub Health. 1993;83:1239-44.
Hatsukami KD, Gust SW, Keenan RM. Physiologic and subjective
changes from smokeless tobacco withdrawal. Clin Pharmacol and Ther.
1987;41:103-107.
Hatsukami DK, Lemmonds C, Zhang Y, et al. Evaluation of
carcinogen exposure in people who used "reduced exposure" tobacco
products. J Natl Cancer
Inst. 2004;96:844-852.
Henley SJ, Connell CJ, Richter P, et al. Tobacco-related
disease mortality among men who switched from cigarettes to spit
tobacco. Tobacco
Control 2007;16:22-28.
Henley SJ, Thun MJ, Connell C, Calle EE. Two large prospective
studies of mortality among men who use snuff or chewing tobacco (United
States). Cancer Causes
Control 2005;16:347-358.
Holm H, Jarvis MJ, Russwell MAH, Feyerabend C. Nicotine intake
and dependence in Swedish snuff takers. Psychopharmacology.
1992;108:507-511.
National Institute of Dental and Craniofacial Research. Spit
Tobacco: A Guide For Quitting. May 2005. Available at:
http://www.nidcr.nih.gov/HealthInformation/DiseasesAndConditions/SpitTobacco/Quitting. Accessed October 23, 2007.
Office of the US Surgeon General. Tobacco Use Among US
Racial/Ethnic Minority Groups. A Report of the Surgeon General. Centers
for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), Office on Smoking and Health.
1998. Available at:
http://www.cdc.gov/tobacco/data_statistics/sgr/sgr_1998/index.htm.
Accessed October 26, 2007.
Office of the US Surgeon General. The Health Consequences of
Using Smokeless Tobacco: A Report of the Surgeon General. Centers for
Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), Office on Smoking and Health.
1986. Available at: http://profiles.nlm.nih.gov/NN/B/B/F/C/. Accessed
October 26, 2007.
Robertson PB, Walsh MM, Greene JC. Oral effects of smokeless
tobacco use by professional baseball players. Adv Dent Res
1997;11:307-312.
Severson HH. Enough Snuff: A Guide for Quitting on Your Own.
6th edition. Eugene, Oregon: Applied
Behavior Science Press. 2002.
Severson HH, Klein K, Lichtenstein E, et al. Smokeless tobacco
use among professional baseball players: Survey results, 1998 to 2003.
Tobacco Control.
2005;14:31-36.
Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration.
Office of Applied Studies, National Survey on Drug Use and Health:
Detailed Tables, 2006. Available at:
http://oas.samhsa.gov/NSDUH/2k5nsduh/tabs/Sect2peTabs37to41.pdf.
Accessed October 22, 2007.
The S.T.O.P. Guide: Smokeless Tobacco Cessation. Applied
Behavioral Science Press. 2002.
U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. The Health
Consequences of Involuntary Smoking: A Report of the Surgeon General.
Washington, DC: Department of Health and Human Services; 1986. Report
No.: Publication No (PHS) 87-839.
Revised: 10/05/2007
|